Home › Forums › Covid Queries › Temperature Measurement Devices › Reply To: Temperature Measurement Devices
Hi all,
B. Deacon:
What cleaning products are you currently using on your Pro 6000s? Are you using what is recommended in the user manual?
Jo Gregory:
Some EBMEs (& private companies) are using ‘black body irradiators’ to test their non-contact thermometers at a spot temperature and then extrapolating the result. It’s not the best way of checking non-contact temperatures (i.e. the extrapolating part), but it is a starting point for some EBMEs. It’s cheap and cheerful, but your EBME might not rate this approach!
Moreover, I’m currently looking at new (Chinese made) non contact and tympanic thermometer ‘in one’ (the T-110). It’s sold by Marsden (https://www.marsden-weighing.co.uk/index.php/ear-forehead-thermometer.html) and it ticks all the right legislation boxes. However, when I tried the Pro 6000 probe tip covers we use, they just kept dropping off. I’m in contact with Marsden (just now) and finding out which tip covers they would recommend and what calibrators they use to check the readings across the patient temperature range (e.g. for Pro 6000s it’s 36.0, 38.5 and 40.0 degree C). I’ll update when I have further information.
Kerry Palmer:
From all the user manuals I’ve read, I haven’t found one manual that states that non-contacts may be used straight away without a ‘climatisation period’ (usually between 20 to 30 minutes for accurate temperature readings). For the Acutes, this shouldn’t be a problem, however, for the Community, in my opinion, non contacts should be used only as a guide temperature because of their potential errors e.g. has to be parallel with forehead at a specific distance, wrinkles, makeup, sweat, hair, user hand movement, environmental conditions, etc. Tympanic thermometers don’t have to consider most of these errors.
If you are looking at the Zeal ACT8000s tympanic thermometers (clinical use/ medical device), remember that these might take 30 minutes to warmup when cold.
FYI (all)
Below is a list of all the tympanic thermometers we currently use. We are an amalgamated and amalgamating (many times & with different partners – on going process), ever changing Community and Mental Health Trust which we are still trying to standardise our medical devices. From a patient safety/ litigation view point, I’m getting rid of all of the ‘Home use’ devices (obviously can’t do this with the current lack of availability of tympanic thermometers {TTs}).
Manufacturer Model TTs recommended location usage from manual
GH Zeal Ltd ACT8000 Clinical Use **When cold requires 30 mins to warm up
Ningbo Huahui Medical Instruments Co., Ltd. ET-100A Home use **No serial number = litigation issues
Omron Ltd Gentle Temp 510 Home use
MSR Ltd ST613CNP Home use
Merlin Medical Ltd TH809 Clinical Use **If held to long, might give higher readings!
Braun GmbH Thermoscan 5 Home use
Welch Allyn International Ltd Thermoscan Pro 4000 Clinical use, ceased production
Welch Allyn International Ltd Thermoscan Pro 6000 Clinical use
In lockdown 1, I decided to read all user manuals of all commonly used devices that were on our medical device asset database. I know this sounds sad, but I am quite normal really! I summarised the lists by clinical or home use. Clinical use means it is a medical device by definition and may be used by clinicians/ Trusts. Home use means it is designed for patient use and not clinicians. If anyone would like the product of my endeavours, I have lists for NIBP (upper arm/ wrist), BP sphygmomanometers (Pocket/ Desk/ Stand/ Wall), Vital signs monitors, Tympanic thermometers, Probe thermometers (Axillary), IR non-contact thermometers, Pulse oximeters (Finger/ Handheld/ Bedside), Ear Irrigators, and Suction machines.
After I read all those exhilarating user manuals and finished my equipment lists, I decided that life would be so much more pleasant if I just gave up hope!
Hope you are all enjoying working from home and I apologise for my lengthy reply…
All the best.
